Sunday, November 15, 2026

What does Jesus mean for us to see? (Fr. James Martin)

     This Sunday's parable, often called the Parable of the Talents, has a majority interpretation and a minority interpretation. The majority interpretation is that the parable is about everyone using the “talents” that God has given them. So the story focuses on the third servant, who doesn't use his “talents.” One problem with that interpretation is that, in Jesus’s time, the word talenton meant the equivalent of a huge sum of wages—15 to 20 years of wages. The word probably didn’t have the connotation of “talent” that it has today. It really stood for a colossal amount of money, like saying “a million dollars.” 

    The minority interpretation is provocative. It’s that the third man believes the owner is unjust: he harvests where he didn’t plant and gathers where he did not scatter. The New Testament scholar Barbara Reid, O.P., wrote in America magazine in 2011, “One who has amassed for himself large amounts of money would be seen as greedy and wicked.” She believes the third servant is the honorable one, because he refuses to participate in a system where the master accrues wealth while others remain poor. 

    Reid sees the parable as Jesus’s warning about the ease with which people can be co-opted by an unjust system, while also encouraging his disciples to expose unfettered greed. She believes that the last verse shows what happens to those who “blow the whistle” on the rich and powerful. The disciples, therefore, are not to take the man going on the journey as a stand-in for God, nor should they take the parable as an encouragement to use their “God-given talents.” Instead, she sees this parable as about the need for the disciples to be faithful during the time between Jesus’s departure and his return, and to go against prevailing attitudes. 

    Isn’t that fascinating? An opposing and majority view, however, comes from John R. Donahue, S.J., another New Testament scholar, who believes that the problem with the servant is the way he judges his master as a “hard” man, when, according to the parable, the master has done nothing to justify the charge. Indeed, to entrust such a large sum demonstrates an almost exorbitant level of trust and generosity. Additionally, the third servant names his motivation for hiding the talent as fear. 

    In his book The Gospel as Parable, Father Donahue writes, "It was his timidity that spelled his downfall, which was not warranted by anything known directly about the master." In a sense, the servant created a master of his own making, rather than letting the master be himself. 

    So what does Jesus mean for us to see? Which interpretation is correct? Well, it’s important to note that this is the third “Parable of Watchfulness” at this point in Matthew's Gospel. It follows a parable of about a servant tending to his master’s house and a parable about bridesmaids who fail to be prepared. In a way, the emphasis is less on the servants and more on the return of the master. As such, it has an apocalyptic, or end time, focus. 

    Whether you like the minority or majority reading, the parable is about being ready. And God’s coming, for which we are to prepare, happens in three ways: the end of our lives, the final coming of Christ and also the ways that God enters our lives each day. 

    So whether you want to focus on the interpretation of Barbara Reid or John Donahue, the main question is this: How do you want to live a life focused on Jesus? Because one day he will return. 

--Fr. James Martin

Image source: Jan Frearks van der Bij, The Parable of the Talents (1962), https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bestand:De_gelijkenis_van_de_talenten.jpg
Quotation source

No comments:

Post a Comment